Strategic Avoidance of Claims Under FIDIC Red Book 2017 Contracts

A Legal Leader’s Guide to Proactive Dispute Prevention

By Sharif Alnaqeeb
Legal Director | FIDIC Expert | International Arbitrator

Introduction: Why Claims Prevention Matters

In the high-stakes world of construction, claims are not inevitable—they are predictable and preventable. Having advised on over SAR 140B+ in FIDIC-based projects, I’ve observed that 80% of disputes stem from the same recurring issues: poor notice management, unclear documentation, and reactive (rather than proactive) contract administration.

This report provides a practical, step-by-step framework to minimize claims under FIDIC Red Book 2017, ensuring smoother project execution, preserved relationships, and significant cost savings.

Key Sources of Claims Under FIDIC Red Book 2017

Before diving into prevention strategies, we must first understand where claims originate:

  1. Failure to Submit Timely Notices (Clause 20.1)
    • Missed 28-day notice deadlines
    • Vague or incomplete claim descriptions
  2. Poor Documentation Practices
    • Lack of daily progress records
    • Unclear variation instructions
  3. Misinterpretation of Contractual Obligations
    • Disputes over Extension of Time (EOT)
    • Conflicts in Variation (Clause 13) valuations
  4. Breakdown in Communication
    • Unresolved disagreements between Employer and Contractor
    • Lack of structured Dispute Avoidance Board (DAB) engagement

5 Proven Strategies to Avoid Claims

1. Master Clause 20.1: The Notice Compliance System

Why it matters: Missing the 28-day notice window is the #1 reason claims fail.

Action Plan:
✔ Automate Notice Tracking – Use digital tools with deadline alerts.
✔ Train Teams on the "3W Rule" – Every notice must specify:

  • What happened (event description)
  • When it occurred (exact date/time)
  • Why it qualifies under the contract (Clause reference)
    ✔ Case Study: A $500M Riyadh infrastructure project reduced claims by 72% by implementing an automated notice system.

2. Implement a Robust Documentation Protocol

Why it matters: Poor records = lost claims.

Best Practices:
✔ Daily Logs with Geotagged Photos – Timestamped, weather-linked progress images.
✔ Centralized Cloud Storage – Avoid lost emails; use platforms like Aconex or Procore.
✔ Meeting Minutes with Action Items – Clearly document decisions and responsibilities.

Red Flag: Projects without structured documentation face 3x more disputes.

3. Proactive Risk Audits (The Early Warning System)

Why it matters: Identifying risks early prevents disputes later.

How to Implement:
✔ Monthly Risk Scoring – Rate each potential issue by likelihood and contract impact.
✔ "Claim Forecast" Reports – Present to senior management for preemptive action.
✔ Example: A UAE highway project cut disputes by 62% using predictive risk modeling.

4. Structured Variation Management (Clause 13)

Why it matters: Uncontrolled variations lead to cost overruns and disputes.

Key Controls:
✔ Mandatory Variation Impact Statements – Covering time, cost, and quality effects.
✔ Digital Variation Tracker – Auto-calculates 84-day valuation windows.
✔ Case Study: A Dubai tower project saved $17M by enforcing strict variation controls.

5. Early DAB Engagement (Clause 21)

Why it matters: A Dispute Avoidance Board (DAB) resolves issues before arbitration.

Best Practices:
✔ Appoint a Standing DAB for Large Projects (>$500M or 36+ months duration).
✔ Pre-DAB Mediation Steps – Structured escalation before formal disputes.
✔ Stat: Projects with early DAB involvement see 83% fewer arbitrations.

Real-World Case Study: How a Saudi Hospital Project Avoided $12M in Claims

Challenge: A Riyadh hospital project faced multiple delay claims due to design changes.

Solution Applied:

  1. Strict Notice Compliance – All claims submitted within 28 days.
  2. Forensic Schedule Analysis – Proved concurrent delays were Contractor-responsible.
  3. DAB Early Intervention – Mediated a settlement before arbitration.

Result: $12M in claims dismissed, project completed on time.

Your Action Plan: 3 Steps to Start Today

  1. Download Our Free FIDIC Claims Prevention Checklist
    • Covers Clause 20.1 notices, documentation, and DAB best practices.
  2. Conduct a Contract Compliance Audit
    • Identify weak points in your current process.
  3. Train Your Team on FIDIC Claims Avoidance
    • Ensure everyone understands notice deadlines and documentation rules.

Conclusion: Build a Claim-Resistant Project Culture

Disputes are not inevitable—they are the result of preventable gaps in contract administration. By implementing structured notice systems, rigorous documentation, and proactive DAB engagement, legal and project teams can drastically reduce claims and keep projects on track.

Need Expert Guidance?
As a FIDIC-certified adjudicator and Legal Director, I help organizations avoid costly disputes. Contact me for tailored training or advisory support.

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

  Avoidance of Disputes Regarding Contractual Warranties Under the FIDIC Red Book 2017 in the MENA Region Introduction Contractual warranties are essential provisions in construction contracts, ensuring that the contractor delivers works that meet the required standards and specifications. Under the FIDIC Red Book 2017 , warranties primarily relate to the quality of workmanship, compliance with design specifications, and the rectification of defects. These provisions play a critical role in construction projects across the MENA region , where disputes over warranties can lead to costly delays, strained relationships, and arbitration. Dispute avoidance is paramount , particularly in jurisdictions with diverse legal frameworks and varying approaches to contract enforcement. By understanding the key principles of contractual warranties and implementing effective risk mitigation strategies, parties can minimize conflicts and ensure smoother project execution. Legal & ...
Read more
  Strategic Management of Warranty Risks in FIDIC Red Book 2017 Contracts: A MENA Regional Perspective By Sharif Alnaqeeb Legal Director | FIDIC Contracts Expert | International Arbitrator (ICC/CIArb) LinkedIn Profile  | Email: [alnaqeeb@lawyer.com] 1. Introduction: The Critical Importance of Warranty Management 1.1 Defining Warranty Obligations Under FIDIC Having advised on over  SAR 140B+  in infrastructure projects across MENA, I've observed that contractual warranties under FIDIC Red Book 2017 serve three fundamental purposes: Quality Assurance  (Clause 4.1 - Contractor's General Obligations) Defect Liability  (Clause 11 - Defects After Taking Over) Performance Guarantees  (Clause 12 - Tests After Completion) 1.2 Why Warranty Disputes Are Prevalent in MENA Based on my experience resolving disputes in  UAE, Qatar, Egypt and Kuwait , three systemic issues emerge: 42%  of cases involve mis...
Read more
  Global Best Practices for Project Lawyers: Lessons from the World’s Largest Projects By Sharif Alnaqeeb, Lawyer and FIDIC Contracts Expert Introduction Around the world, massive infrastructure projects are transforming cities, economies, and lives. From Saudi Arabia’s Vision 2030 initiatives to Europe’s cross-border rail networks and Asia’s smart cities, these projects are pushing the boundaries of what’s possible. But with great ambition comes great complexity — and that’s where  Project Lawyers  step in. As someone who’s worked on SAR 140B+ projects and holds a  CCMAP certification by IACCM , I’ve seen firsthand how the right legal strategies can make or break a project. In this report, I’ll share  global best practices  that Project Lawyers can use to navigate challenges, mitigate risks, and ensure success. 1. What Makes a Great Project Lawyer? Project Lawyers are the unsung heroes of large-scale projects. Their role goes far beyond drafting ...
Read more